| 2024 | Rishi Patel | 41 balls |
| 2023 | Sean Abbott | 34 balls |
| 2022 | Paul Stirling | 46 balls |
| 2021 | L S Livingstone | 42 balls |
| 2020 | J M Clarke | 44 balls |
| 2019 | C S Delport | 38 balls |
| 2018 | M J Guptill | 35 balls |
| 2017 | S Afridi | 42 balls |
| 2016 | T Kohler-Cadmore | 43 balls |
| 2015 | D J Willey | 40 balls |
| 2014= | S W Billings | 46 balls |
| 2014= | D T Christian | 46 balls |
| 2013 | D I Stevens | 44 balls |
| 2012 | S B Styris | 37 balls |
| 2011 | K J O’Brien | 44 balls |
| 2010 | A C Gilchrist | 47 balls |
| 2009 | V S Solanki | 47 balls |
| 2008 | G R Napier | 44 balls |
| 2007 | M J North | 73 balls |
| 2006 | M A Ealham | 45 balls |
| 2005 | I D Blackwell | 67 balls |
| 2004 | R Johnson | 63 balls |
| 2003 | D R Martyn | 65 balls |
| 2002 | M V Fleming | 66 balls |
| 2001 | I J Harvey | 61 balls |
| 2000 | D S Lehmann | 89 balls |
| 1999 | A Flintoff | 61 balls |
| 1998= | C L Hooper | 72 balls |
| 1998= | A D Brown | 72 balls |
| 1997 | G D Lloyd | 73 balls |
| 1996 | G D Lloyd | 70 balls |
| 1995 | C L Cairns | 65 balls |
| 1994 | K R Rutherford | 71 balls |
| 1993= | P Johnson | 73 balls |
| 1993= | M P Maynard | 73 balls |
| 1992 | M P Speight | 62 balls |
| 1991 | I D Austin | 61 balls |
| 1990 | T M Moody | 36 balls |
| 1989 | D J Bicknell | 69 balls |
| 1988 | G A Hick | 79 balls |
| 1987 | R O Butcher | 73 balls |
| 1986 | I V A Richards | 48 balls |
| 1985 | I T Botham | 50 balls |
| 1984 | M W Gatting | 79 minutes |
| 1983 | S J O’Shaughnessy | 35 minutes |
| 1982 | I T Botham | 52 minutes |
| 1981 | S T Clarke | 62 minutes |
| 1980 | I V A Richards | 66 minutes |
| 1979 | M J Procter | 57 minutes |
| 1978 | C G Greenidge | 82 minutes |
| 1977 | C M Old | 37 minutes |
| 1976 | A P E Knott | 70 minutes |
| 1975 | R N S Hobbs | 44 minutes |
| 1974 | G S Sobers | 83 minutes |
| 1973 | Asif Iqbal | 72 minutes |
| 1972 | Majid Khan | 70 minutes |
| 1971 | B F Davison | 63 minutes |
| 1970 | G Boycott | 222 balls* |
| 1969 | C Milburn | 163 balls** |
| 1968 | T W Graveney | 174 balls** |
| 1967 | B L D’Oliveira | 173 balls** |
| 1966 | K F Barrington | 122 balls** |
Between the Second World War and 1966 the Trophy was not presented.